Patrick Mahomes is an elite quarterback in real-life football, but that doesn’t always translate seamlessly into fantasy value. Dynasty leagues remain active throughout the offseason, and the upcoming 2025 NFL Draft is set to further ignite trading activity in these formats. In superflex leagues, where starting quarterbacks are a premium asset, owners often overpay to secure stability at the position. If you’re aiming to boost the overall talent on your fantasy roster, now might be the perfect time to consider selling high on Patrick Mahomes or Carolina Panthers quarterback Bryce Young.
Patrick Mahomes and Bryce Young: Top Fantasy Football “Sell” Candidates
As of the latest rankings from KeepTradeCut, Patrick Mahomes sits at QB6 in fantasy football. This is a fair valuation for a player widely regarded as one of the game’s premier talents, but his on-field production doesn’t quite align with such a lofty ranking.
Mahomes ended the 2024 season as the QB11, and it’s challenging to envision a significant leap forward in 2025. With Matt Nagy returning as offensive coordinator, the Chiefs’ playbook will likely continue to emphasize the short passing game. Rookie Xavier Worthy flashed potential at times but failed to emerge as a reliable threat in the passing attack. Rashee Rice is back from a season-ending injury, Travis Kelce is another year older, and the offensive line faces potential decline with Joe Thuney now in Chicago and career backup Jaylon Moore earning $15 million annually.
If you were assembling a real football team, Mahomes might be the first name off the board. In fantasy football, however, his current value could net you the 1.01 pick plus additional assets. Alternatively, you might trade Mahomes for a younger quarterback like Drake Maye along with an extra draft pick. Parting with a talent like Mahomes is never easy, but the fantasy value he commands right now is too enticing to overlook.
Bryce Young: The Real Deal?
After a sluggish start to his NFL career, Carolina Panthers quarterback Bryce Young finally showed signs of life in the latter half of the 2024 season. Stepping in for an injured Andy Dalton, Young finished as the QB20 despite starting just 12 games. He’s currently valued at QB21—a reasonable price, but perhaps a touch steep for a quarterback yet to fully prove himself.
Young notched three top-eight finishes in the final six weeks of the season, but a closer look reveals these performances may not be sustainable. He required 46 passing attempts to secure a QB8 finish in Week 13, leaned on a season-high 68 rushing yards in Week 16 to claim QB2 status (his next-best rushing total was just 30 yards), and torched a struggling Atlanta Falcons defense to take QB1 honors in Week 18.
Could Bryce Young sustain his upward trajectory and solidify himself as a franchise quarterback? Absolutely—it’s within the realm of possibility. But it could just as easily be a fleeting hot streak. QB21 isn’t an outrageous asking price, yet Young remains an easy sell when compared to Dallas Cowboys quarterback Dak Prescott, currently valued at QB22. Though older, Prescott has a firm grip on his starting role, pairs with elite receiver CeeDee Lamb, and is expected to return healthy for the regular season. He offers greater consistency and a comparable ceiling to Young.
Expert Insight: With the fantasy market heating up ahead of the 2025 Draft, selling Mahomes or Young could be a strategic move to optimize your roster. Weigh your long-term needs and current market trends carefully before making a decision!
