Hailee Steinfeld—actress, musician, and fiancée of Buffalo Bills quarterback Josh Allen—has fans raising eyebrows about her true loyalties after a surprising YouTube appearance. Steinfeld joined “Hot Ones Versus” to promote her upcoming film “Sinners” alongside co-star Michael B. Jordan. The twist came when Jordan challenged her to name three positive things about the Kansas City Chiefs, the Bills’ fiercest on-field nemesis and the bane of Allen’s postseason dreams.
Steinfeld hesitated but powered through. “I can find nice things to say about anybody, even if I—or we—don’t like them,” she started. “Yellow and red really suit them well. They’re loud… that’s great, you want that from a fanbase. They go all out for their team.” While her praise was lukewarm at best, her willingness to compliment the Chiefs has left some Bills fans wondering: Could Steinfeld secretly be rooting for the enemy?
The Bills-Chiefs rivalry is no laughing matter. In their latest AFC Championship clash, Kansas City edged out Buffalo 32-29, crushing the Bills’ hopes of reaching their first Super Bowl since 1993 while marching to their third straight title game. With Allen fresh off a 2024 NFL MVP win, that loss to the Chiefs still stings for him and the Bills Mafia faithful. Yet here’s Steinfeld, casually tossing kind words at KC on camera—even if it was just a challenge—fueling speculation about where her heart really lies.
Though Allen hasn’t snagged a Super Bowl ring, he did put one on Steinfeld’s finger, with the couple getting engaged in November. Dating since May 2023, they’ve recently been spotted together at Steinfeld’s movie premiere and at JFK Airport in New York after the trip. No wedding date has been announced, but after her Chiefs shoutout, some Bills fans might jokingly suggest she wear a Chiefs jersey down the aisle. Was this just a lighthearted “Hot Ones” moment, or does Steinfeld harbor a hidden fondness for Josh Allen’s biggest rival? Only time will tell!
